What if money and investing was easy to understand?

My newsletter can make it simple. Get my best lessons, stories, and tips each Friday.

What if money and investing was easy to understand?

My newsletter can make it simple. Get my best lessons, stories, and tips each Friday.

Which investing app to choose?

Which investing app is best? (Raiz vs Spaceship vs CommSec Pockets)

Table of Contents

Let's go through the three popular investing apps in Australia right now. 

These are the micro-investing apps that are a mobile-focused approach to investing in stocks and shares here in Australia.

No longer do you need to go through advisors or brokers to trade shares and stocks all in a handy, colourful app.

From my experience, it's such a simpler and cleaner way for beginners to more experienced investors to invest.

I will dive into the three key players today and show you what they can all do and individually how they might work for you.

Take a shortcut to any of the specific apps here:

Referral codes for Spaceship and Raiz (September 2021)

Currently, Spaceship and Raiz have bonuses for those creating new accounts. I know some of you might be looking for them so here they are at the top.

For Spaceship, receive a bonus of $10 when you invest $5 for the first time, join here using code S8P1Q355VX.

For Raiz, get a $10 bonus when you create a free account here

How do they work

Just like any app, you download it onto your phone.

Because it's a financial investment product you will need to create an account then enter some personal details. You will need to set up a connecting bank account as well so the app can direct debit money across when you want to invest.

To start investing money you will need to select which portfolio or investment option your money goes into. Each app has its own differences as I will explain.

In terms of cost, you will pay a fee to either make a trade (buy or sell an investment) or pay a percentage fee based on your balance each month. 

Are investing apps worth it?

Yes, they are. While they look flashy and might feel gimmicky, you can use these as a serious way to build wealth. 

These micro-investing apps have been around for the last 4-5 years. I took notice of Acorns when it launched in Australia (now known as Raiz) and have used it for over 5 years now.

I've spent the last few years using and trying them out and have found them very worthwhile.

I've even cut back on using traditional online brokers as these investing apps are so much easier.

Yeah, they are nice to look at, but behind them are some pretty get mechanics to set you up with an investment portfolio.

I'll get into the differences between a few, but one good thing about these apps is that they are targeting the new investor so make it easy to get going plus help you out with some educational content. 

Also, you can get started with very little money – like $5 and work your way from there. It's like savings.

What makes investing apps great?

A product like Raiz or Spaceship, and now Commsec Pockets have several features that make it an excellent option for investors:

Accessibility

You can literally download an investing app right now and sign up on the spot. Many of them use plain English and encourage new investors, so make it easy to understand.

Bypass brokers

Replace the full-service stockbrokers who give you advice and put trades in for you. They also replace the online broker platforms to buy and sell stocks (like SelfWealth). These investing apps are all in one and do the buy/sell steps for you, and it feels so much simpler.

Trying To Up Your Investing Game? Join my online course on how to invest in shares and the stock market. 

Low barriers to entry

Most brokers need you to put $500 into an investment to get started and even then there are fees on top of it. These apps reduce barriers. With Raiz or Spaceship, you only need $5 to get started. 

Low cost

Some brokers charge $20,$30, $40+ per trade. That's money you spend just to buy or sell with your money. Investing apps were built with low costs in mind. Comsec pockets for example only charge $2 a trade.

Less admin

For apps that create diversified portfolios like Raiz or Spaceship there is less paperwork and upkeep than if you bought ETFs or stocks individually. Personally, I hate all the paperwork that comes with stocks and can't seem to get it digitised. 

With something like RAIZ you will invest in multiple ETFs but only have one tax statement to handle. Simples.

Easy to automate

Set up recurring investments and get automatic rebalancing done, which you can't do through traditional brokers

For example, you can set up $100 to invest in your app of choice every fortnight or month. This gets automatically invested and goes to work like your savings account word. 

These apps are great for set and forget strategies where you want to set up a transfer and let the product do the rest.

Educational

These investing apps cater to the fact many of their users are first-time investors. Because of this, the apps are very supportive and informative of those learning the investing ropes. Through the language used (no jargon) and helpful articles or explainers.

New investors feel supported with helpful cues, tips, and updates from some apps that give you confidence and comfort around the investing process.

What investing apps are there?

Let's look at the most prominent investing apps in Australia – Raiz, Spaceship Invest and Commsec Pockets.

First came Raiz in around 2016, then Spaceship back in 2018 and since then CommSec Pockets was launched in 2019.

Even though each of the apps look and feel similar in how they work there are some key differences.

  • RAIZ have you invest in a mix of ETFs that are preselected or cusotmised to your chooosing.
  • Spaceship is like a managed fund where the team pick stocks actively and you just invest in that.
  • CommSec pockets is more DIY where you select the specific ETF and how much exactly you want.

Full disclaimer: I invest in each of these three platforms. I've had experience buying, selling, changing portfolios and paying fees for each. This article is all based on my own experiences.

I'll go into each and explain what they offer, then provide some reasons one or the other might be suitable for you. 


Raiz Breakdown

If you want a simple, all in one place to build diversified wealth then Raiz is a great option

Acorns Australia was the original investing app in Australia. It was an offshoot of the American version which still exists today over there.

In Australia, it's now called Raiz and is an Australian listed company on the ASX.

Raiz is what I call a “do it for me” investment product.

You set up an account, pick a portfolio and add money to it. You can automate this all, so Raiz literally does it all for you.

Investing with Raiz

There are two ways to add money to Raiz. You can add in money manually or automatically (direct debited from your account).

Raiz gained popularity through what's called the “round up” feature.

When purchasing anything on a nominated account, for example, a coffee for $3.50, the cost is rounded up to the nearest dollar. So if you spend $3.50 then  50 cents is sent to Raiz. This is helpful if you are doing several purchases on a particular card. You'll find over time the pot is filling up.

This is how I started. I don't do this anymore as I contribute a set amount on a fortnightly basis instead but it's easy to turn on and off this feature which is not mandatory to use.

As a new Raiz user, you can use my referral code to receive $10 when you make your first investment. It's free to set up so check it out. Here's the link.

The beauty of Raiz is that they will take any amount of cash and invest it, which means they will buy a fraction of a share for you. No more do you need to wait until you have the exact price of the share to buy, you can do it straight away (starting even just $5).

There is also an option for investing on behalf of your kids. This isn't what you might think though. Raiz doesn't invest in your kid's names, it only labels some of the money that you invest to them. Nothing functional here really.

Raiz's portfolio options

Don't be deceived by the bright and shiny looking app, Raiz has some serious investing powers

Raiz has 7 prebuilt portfolios to pick from as well as an option to build your own custom portfolios (which is what I personally do).

The preset portfolios are made up of well-established ETFs that are a mix of local, global stocks and bonds, and cash.

Each portfolio has a different balance of stocks and bonds from the conservative option (22% stocks) to the aggressive growth option (90% stocks). These labels are similar to what you see for your superannuation

There is also the Sapphire portfolio which includes 5% bitcoin, with 69% in stocks and the rest in bonds. Probably one of the easiest most diversified ways to get crypto into your investment portfolio.

Custom portfolios also allow you to invest in Bitcoin (with a maximum of 5%)

Custom portfolios

In 2021, Raiz released custom portfolios. This was a game-changer as it meant you can build your own all-in-one diversified portfolio. Instead of buying a number of ETFs individually, you can put them altogether through Raiz and just put your money into one investment.

What you have to do is pick which ETFs you want in and how much of your portfolio they make up.

The limit is that there are only 16 ETFs to pick from (plus Bitcoin) but in reality, they are all strong established ETFs that are likely to meet your needs.

Once you select your ETFs, you'll need to determine how much of your overall portfolio it'll make as a percentage.

See my screenshot here of a test portfolio I built. As you make selections Raiz tells you the risk scale, with more stocks or crypto meaning it will be higher risk.

The ETFs you can pick from include

  • AAA – Cash ETF
  • STW – Aus Large Cap Stocks
  • IAA – Asia Large Cap Stocks
  • IEU – Europe Large Cap Stocks
  • IAF – Aus Bonds
  • RCB – Aus Corporate Bonds
  • IVV – US Large Cap Stocks
  • RARI – Aus Socially Responsible
  • ETHI – Global Socially Responsible
  • FAIR – Aus Sustainable Leaders
  • NDQ – Nasdaq 100
  • VGE – Emerging Markets
  • IOO – Global 100
  • IXJ – Global Healthcare
  • VEFI – Ethically Consious Global Bonds
  • VSO – Australian Small Companies
  • and Bitcoin (but no more than 5% of overall portfolio)

Up until this was launched I owned many of these ETFs individually through SelfWealth and CommSec Pockets.

The problem with that was if I wanted to invest in them i had to manually do that on an individual basis. So if I wanted to add money to 5 different ETFs that would cost me for each of those trades.

Now with Raiz, I can put money straight into the portfolio via the app and it gets cut up then sent to all the selections I have.

I will be investing in Raiz through a custom portfolio from now on. There are higher costs for this portfolio type but feel it is a very cheap investing service, saving me time as well.

You can change this portfolio option at any time and always go back to the preselected portfolios or change your ETF/percentage mix as you go.

Raiz's Fees 

Raiz makes its money from charging you a monthly fee, as opposed to brokers that charge you when you buy or sell stocks.

I feel that this makes it helpful for those who want to add ni smaller amounts or more regular investments.

Raiz's fees most recently changed (increased) from April 1, 2021.

The ongoing costs for Raiz are reasonable if you have over $7,500 invested.

For the 7 premixed portfolios (everything but custom and Sapphire) Its $3.50 a month when under $15k, then .27% of your balance for those holding more than $15,000. Sapphire is $3.50 a month for all balances or $42 a year.

$3.50 a month is a lot if you have only a chump change in your account. You really need to get to at least $7500 as quickly as possible.

For example, if you have $500 in Raiz, the fees would be $42 a year or 8.4% of your money that will go to fees.  

The fees for custom portfolios are higher, with balances below $20,000 being charged $4.50 a month, and balances above $20,000 costing .275% pa.

Fees are due each month and charged from the balance in your account.

Raiz is completely transparent with its pricing and while they do infrequently increase their fees, it is still an affordable option as you do not have to pay to trade (add or withdrawal money) and they keep your portfolio well balanced.

Other features

Raiz also has a rewards program. You buy something through the apps from one provider and a percentage of that purchase gets sent back to your account. I never use this or think about it but know some people who have done well utilising this. Things like surveys or cashback from online stores are pretty common rewards included. 

Raiz has a super fund, which is the equivalent of the portfolios I mentioned (minus the bitcoin option). Personally, I don't have my super in Raiz and feel that their insurance offer isn't the strongest.

Benefits

  • Investing automatically either by a set amount or by rounding up your purchases
  • Select from a broad range of well-built portfolios
  • Buy fractional shares so can invest immediately 
  • Rewards program
  • Sustainable options 
  • All in one / set and forget option
  • Need little money to start with

Considerations

  • Costly if balance under $7.5k
  • Easy to make changes (maybe too easy)
  • Limited to invest in predetermined portfolios, or selected ETFs

Uniqueness factor 

For me its these three all in the one platform:

  • Fractional investing (any amount of money you have can be invested)
  • Rebalancing
  • Reinvestment (automated investing)

This means Raiz will allow you to invest with whatever money you have, will make sure your portfolio is balanced the way you prefer and reinvest any dividends for you.

I believe Raiz is the cheapest way to have the three things done automatically done for you.

The roundups feature is a bonus for me. It got me going with the product, but you need to do more than that to truly build wealth.

Ready to start Investing?

Join my quick and easy online course that gives you the skills, knowledge, and confidence to start investing in the stock market.

No jargon, no confusion, just the help you need to invest in shares confidently.


Spaceship Breakdown 

If you are looking to invest in an actively managed fund of growth stocks, then Spaceship is a great option

Spaceship Voyager is a spin-off from Spaceship Super that launched back in 2017.

Their philosophy is to look towards “where the world is going” so are big on tech companies across the world. You've all heard of these names Amazon, Adobe, IBM, Google, A2 milk, AfterPay, Tesla are all prominent. 

They are very transparent in how they operate which makes it easy to understand their offer, which is that it's a managed fund of selected stocks (As opposed to a group of ETFs).

Investing with Spaceship

The app is very similar to Raiz in that you add money to your account and it gets invested on your behalf. 

You can set up a recurring investment or manually add. There is no round-up option like Raiz so it is much simpler an interface to manage.  

Start with Spaceship and get $10! Use the code S8P1Q355VX after you sign up for an account here, then once you deposit $5 you'll get a $10 bonus.

Spaceship's portfolio options

There are three investment options to pick from

Spaceship Universe, Spaceship Origin, Spaceship Earth (new in 2020)
  • Spaceship Origin which tracks several companies passively (companies rarely change)
  • Spaceship Universe which is actively managing and the included companies can change often (higher risk, higher return)
  • Spaceship Earth which contains companies that provide a positive impact to the Earth (according to the Spaceship team)

I consider all three a “fund” in that they are a group of companies you buy into. You don't select which companies are in but put your money towards one of the three.

For me, the jury is out if the Spaceship Earth is a meaningful fund. It contains companies focused on supporting a sustainable planet, but their screening is questionable. For example, they screen out companies working on nuclear energy even though it is a clean, renewal energy source (a personal gripe of these “ethical investment” types.

Spaceship allows you to pick more than one portfolio to invest in, meaning if you like all three then you can invest in all three. Previously you were limited to just one portfolio per account.

Your Spaceship Voyager portfolios to pick from when signing up

It’s helpful that they are transparent as they outline all the stocks included in each option on their website. You can look at the performance for each pick in a nice-to-digest way (good for when you research).

Note that all portfolios are 100% stocks. There is no defensive component which means it is more aggressive/risky than holding a balanced portfolio that includes fixed interest and bonds as Raiz does.

Spaceship's Fees

Spaceship fees are lean and simple.

For your first $5000 investing is free. This makes it a great way to get started investing without worrying about cost.

The fees after $5000 are minuscule – .05% per year for the Index and .10% per year for the Universe portfolio.

This is any amount over $5000.

If you had $10,000 in the app, you would be charged only $25 a year. This is extremely cheap.

Other features

One thing Spaceship does well over the others is educate you on investing.

It has a helpful learn section and there is a good feed on investing support and help within the app.

It can help you feel confident and supported, with the app being more than just a balance on your screen.

Want a video walkthrough of Spaceship? Sit over my shoulder and watch me spend 10 minutes explaining every aspect of the app

If you like purple or rockets, Spaceship is for you

Benefits

  • Free for first $5000 invested
  • Lowest cost of all investing apps
  • Simple pair of portfolios to pick from
  • Well diversified
  • Helpful content and education on investing
  • Can start with only $5
  • Can be automated

Considerations

  • You need faith in the Spaceship investment team 
  • Options are actively managed rather than passively
  • Portfolios are 100% stocks

Uniqueness

Hand-picked mix of stocks and companies with a tech focus.

Cheap and easy to get started and get knowledge on investing. 

Very transparent in the companies included in your portfolios


CommSec Pockets Breakdown

If you feel confident with investing and want to pick specific ETFs to add to your portfolio then CommSec Pockets is for you

Connected with CommSec, Pockets is a new way to buy ETFs at a low cost via an easy-to-use app.

Pockets are more DIY than Raiz or Spaceship, but a still cheap and convenient. Pockets act like a low-cost broker where you can buy and sell a selected mix of ETFs.

Investing with CommSec Pockets

You need to have an existing CommBank account or CommSec account to open an account with Pockets.

Since I had neither, I opened a CommSec account so had to go through the process of doing that just so I could then set up pockets.

What's a bit confusing is that Pockets is completely separate to CommSec standard'. This means your CommSec standard and CommSec Pockets investments show separately if you have both.

Another point of difference from Raiz or Spaceship is that once you transfer money in it is not invested automatically (unless you set up automatic investments).  

The process works like this

  • Transfer money from your bank to CommSec account
  • Manually select option to invest in via the app 
  • Complete trade

Very much like a traditional broker experience.

You can set up automatic investments, but you will need money in your account for this to happen. If you wanted to do this you would need to transfer money to your CDIA account in CommSec and pockets would take money out of this at the interval you set.

CommSec Pocket's ETF options

Pockets don't have pre-built funds or portfolios to pick from.

You have seven ETFs that are available to buy like any other broker on the ASX. These ETFs are similar to what Raiz use to make up their portfolios, but in this case, you pick them individually. In a way, you are building your own portfolio here so more control than Raiz.

  • IOZ – 200 Australian companies
  • IOO – 100 Global companies
  • ETHI – Global sustainability leaders 
  • IXJ – Global Healthcare 
  • IEM – Emerging markets 
  • NDQ – Global tech companies
  • SYI – High Dividend Yield Fund

Personally, I like all these ETFs. In particular, I own IOZ, ETHI, and IEM.

The reason why IOZ was picked as opposed to VAS or A200 is the price. In Pockets you need to buy the entire stock (not a fraction of it like Raiz or Spaceship). IOZ trades around $25 which is lower than VAS at $75 or A200 at $100 or so. The concept of the app is to make investing more accessible and affordable so buying into Australian stocks at $25 is that.

Note that there is no option for defensive ETFs like bonds or fixed interest which would really make this app become all in one for DIY investors. You can of course buy these at other brokers or hold money in bank accounts to add “defense”.  

Pockets are like a …err pocket-sized investing app that's nice and yellow

CommSec Pocket's Fees

Fees are simple and clear.

  • $2 per trade if under $10000
  • If over $1000 then it's .20%
    • eg. if you invest $1500 the cost is $3

There are no ongoing fees (like the other apps) so if you were to invest semi-regular then this might be a cheaper option.

Considering CommSec can charge $19.95 for the same trade, so it's significantly cheaper if you were buying the same ETFs anyway. 

While $2 is cheap, if you are buying or selling often it might not be the best option.

If you were buying fortnightly or monthly basis like I do – you might rack up costs of $52 a year if fortnightly or $24 a year if monthly. 

Other features

The app is quite nice to use. It is clean and easy to manage. I feel it is still being treated as an experiment by CommBank as they have done that with new apps previously (remember the Kaching app?).

The tone of voice is helpful to new investors and every step of the trading process has information to help you understand what is happening. 

One thing that I love is that it does not give you daily changes in your balance.

Most brokers once you sign in will show you exactly what your balance did for that day. This isn’t helpful as it grabs at your emotions telling you you’ve won or lost. You really need to be looking at investments long-term (that's why I use Sharesight).

Benefits 

As a DIY investor, rather than a set and forget type, you can have more control over exactly what you are investing in. You can select specific ETFs based on what’s important to you. 

Whether it be a region like global or Australia, which sector, or even a high dividend-paying ETF.

It is a convenient step up if you already have a CommSec account. Add the app and start investing from your phone today.

If you want to build a simple investment portfolio yourself, this is a handy way to start. 

You pay per trade rather than a recurring fee, so if you wanted to drop a large amount in then it is a better option as you pay once. 

Consideration

  • While you can invest from $50, the $2 fee would make it costly for trades less than $200. I recommend $500 plus a trade if you want to keep things low cost
  • To a new investor it may not be obvious what to pick from, so research of the ETFs and how to build a portfolio is recommended
  • All investments are 100% stocks – no diversification across asset types
  • You cannot buy fractionally so you need the exact amount to cover the cost of shares

Uniqueness

  • Build a DIY ETF portfolio through the one app. 
  • Select your own individual ETFs at a fraction of the cost.
  • Setup recurring investments through a broker.

Summary table of investing apps

To help you work out how these apps fare side by side

FeatureRaizSpaceShipCommSec
Investment 
system
Automated
Fractional
Diversified
Rebalanced
Customisable
Automated
Fractional
Passive or actively managed fund
Automated (if account funded) 7 ETFs to select
Fees$2.5 a month under $10000
.27% of balance over $10000
$4.50 a month for custom portfolios under $20k, .275% with balances over $20k
$0 for first $5000.05% or
.10% for any amount more than $10000
$2 per trade if under $1000
.20% if over $1000
Other featuresRound up
Invest for Kids
Ethical portfolio
Bitcoin
Helpful educational contentWell explained process
Connected to Commsec accounts
Benefits Low cost over $10000
Set and forget
Rebalancing included
Low cost 
Good entry to investing in stocks
Low-cost broker trading
Build DIY portfolio
ConsiderationsCostly if low balance
Very easy to make portfolio changes
Fixed portfolio options
Spaceship investment team pick companies in portfoliosNeed understanding of ETFs and what you are investing in 
Can be costly if trading frequently

Ready to start Investing?

Join my quick and easy online course that gives you the skills, knowledge, and confidence to start investing in the stock market.

No jargon, no confusion, just the help you need to invest in shares confidently.

Quick questions on investing apps

By no means is this in any way financial advice. It is general advice and please take your own situation into account. See my posts on budgeting and saving for help in those areas so you understand what you can afford to invest. 

How do I find the right investing app for me?

The best way to find out is to try them all. That’s what I did.

They are simple to set up and easy to understand.

Can I invest with little to no money?

Yep. Like $5.

And before you say “$5 isn't going to make a difference” let me ask you this.

If I gave you a dollar a day for 10 years would you take it?

That’s over $3600 dollars, which I’m probably not going to notice gone. It would have to be annoying handing over $1 every single day though. 

If you do only have $1 a day spare then your best option is to save up a bit of it until you reach $50 or so and try an app out. 

Watch it grow (or not!) and see how investing works. 

What is the best app for investing?

Raiz with a custom portfolio is my choice.

The ability to handpick ETFs, then invest on a regular basis with no brokerage fees is something I find most valuable.

Once you set things up upfront it becomes so ridiculously easy and makes anything else hard work.

Note that I think Raiz is suited for those with or $5k or more in their accounts looking to increase it on a regular basis.

If not then CommSec Pockets or Spaceship are also great cheaper options that are very low maintenance.

What is the best investment app for beginners?

If you are brand new to investing and want to try something, I would suggest Spaceship.

Mainly due to it being free until you have a $5000 balance. 

Your money is invested in 100% stocks so you'll have a more volatile experience of how the markets work and the educational content included in the app is very helpful. 

Are these investing apps just starter apps?

No. They are complex enough to help you build a well-diversified investment portfolio that can build long-term growth.


So which investing app will you choose?

Getting started is important, these apps can help you with that.

They can be a fast way to get starting investing in the market. You can also invest frequently, get confidence in what you know and do.

Realise that even if you do get started with an investing app you can move on to other investment options or tools.

Also, know that these apps are fantastic ways for you to make considerable wealth. There is nothing they can’t do that will stop you from investing long term. 

If you’re not already investing, and have some money available to invest either regularly or once-off then consider these investing apps.

If you are looking for more help or even a walkthrough on how these apps work and can fit into your investing life then check out my course on how to invest in shares.

Want to invest in shares but don’t know where to start? Join the New Investor Bootcamp

Get FREE money and investing tips each Friday you won’t find anywhere else via my newsletter.

All my content goes exclusively to my email list first

Receive my best ideas, lessons, stories on money, investing, & personal finance every Friday. I’ll send you 3 ebooks and my best  articles right away as a thank you.

Ready to start investing? Join my easy-to-follow online course that gives you the skills, knowledge, and confidence to start investing in the stock market. Find out more.

Keep reading...

Ready to learn about money like a normal person?

Get my an email each Friday with the money tips and knowledge I’ve used to transform my life, mindset and outlook. No formulas or equations needed.

No spam and 1 click unsubscribe. 

My best stories and tips on both money and investing.

  • Think differently about money
  • Improve your confidence
  • Make better decisions
  • 2 minute read 
  • Free, forever